PRE-ORDERS ARE LIVE FOR STRAWBERRY ICE CREAM MIX! SHIPPING 10/27 // Free Shipping on all orders $20+



A business mentor and taste tester was the inspiration behind our name because he admitted he thought the product was going to taste chalky and strange. We said “What you’re eating is a real, true scoop of ice cream.” His actual testimonial? “It was delicious.” 

Not at the moment.

We are a women-owned business and our mixes are kosher dairy and gluten-free certified. Sprinkles are kosher certified. 

Product Info

All of the things your favorite frozen pint is made of, but in powder form! Heavy cream powder, nonfat milk powder, sugar, salt, and teeny bit of guar gum. 

Hang on, guar gum? Isn’t that a stabilizer? Why use it? 

Yes and yes. There is less than 1% of guar gum, which is derived from guar beans. Its thickens the mixture and slows down the growth of ice crystals. That means thick and creamy ice cream for you! 

All products are naturally shelf-stable (because it's all dry ingredients) up to 18 months! Look for the "Best if used by" date on the back of the pouch. 

In your pantry! Yes, pantry, right next to the can of beans. They'll do best in low humidity environments at 75F or lower. Anything higher may cause the shelf life to shorten. 

Use an airtight plastic container that can go in the freezer. There are a lot of great ice cream storage containers online. Our favorite brand is "Glide-a-Scoop" by Tovolo. 

Pro tip: Place a piece of parchment paper on top of the ice cream to further prevent any ice crystals from forming. Peel off before scooping! Duh.

We can’t physically stop you from doing so, but we strongly advise against it. Each mix was developed with half & half in mind in order to achieve the right flavor and texture. 

Not at the moment, but if you have a flavor idea let us know by emailing us at

We are always testing new flavors and product ideas. Join our mailing list to be the first to hear about what we're going to roll out. It's gonna be good, promise. 

Have no fear, we are in the kitchen working up some stellar mixes just for you! Join our mailing list for new product announcements. 

Please review the product within shop page to see each products allergens. When in doubt, please don’t eat our product, we like you too much.

Store it as far back in the freezer as possible where it’s the coldest. Avoid the freezer door if possible. Make sure your freezer temp is at 0 or lower for optimal freezing. 

Currently our packaging is not recyclable, but we are striving to become more eco-friendly as our business grows.


We ship Monday, Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday. Any order placed after 5pm will ship the next business day.

We offer $5 flat rate shipping for any orders under $30. Anything over $30 is FREE shipping, no promo code needed!

If the shipping gods allow, your package will arrive between 3-5 business days. Tracking information will be sent to your email when it ships. You can also sign up for SMS updates at checkout. And as a last resort, email us at hello@maketruescoops and we will happily answer any of your questions. 

Returns & Exchanges

All sales are final. If your package arrives damaged, email us at with pictures and we will send you a shipping label to send them back to us at no charge. Upon review of the product, we will reship you a new package at no charge.

No, not at this time. 

First time customers will get promo code when they sign up for our newsletter. If you join our mailing list, you’ll be the first to hear about other exclusive deals.

No, so please triple check your order before confirming! 


Not right now, but we will for the holiday season. Stay tuned.

Please email us at and we can review your request. Timing is provided based on the specific request. The decision to accept or deny a request is based on available product inventory.